Performance Review Template Nonprofit

NON-PROFIT EMPLOYEE PERFORMANCE REVIEW AND EVALUATION POLICY

DOCUMENT CONTROL

• Effective Date: [Effective Date]
• Version: 1.0
• Jurisdiction/Scope: [State/Region] / [Organization Name] Organization-Wide

---

1. OFFICIAL NOTICE / DISCLAIMER

NOTICE: This Performance Review Template is an internal operational and human resources policy instrument of [Organization Name] ("Organization"). It is designed to evaluate employee performance, set organizational goals, and document professional development within a non-profit operational framework.

Nothing in this document constitutes an express or implied contract of employment, nor does it alter the "at-will" employment status of any employee (where applicable by local law). The Organization reserves the right to amend, modify, or terminate this evaluation policy or its associated procedures at any time, with or without notice, in accordance with applicable federal, state, and local laws.

---

2. PARTIES & DEFINITIONS

This performance review is executed by and between:

• Employer: [Organization Name], a [State] non-profit corporation exempt under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code, with its principal office located at [Organization Address] ("Organization").
• Employee: [Full Legal Name], holding the title of [Job Title] ("Employee").
• Reviewer: [Full Legal Name], holding the title of [Manager/Supervisor Title] ("Evaluator").
• Review Period: Commencing on [Start Date] and concluding on [End Date].

---

3. OPERATIVE CLAUSES & TERMS

SECTION I: PURPOSE AND OBJECTIVES

1. Scope of Evaluation: This performance review assesses the Employee's execution of assigned duties, adherence to the mission, vision, and values of the Organization, and compliance with internal policies and fiduciary standards.
2. Non-Profit Alignment: As an exempt entity operating for public benefit, the Employee's performance shall be measured against both standard operational competencies and their specific contributions to the Organization's tax-exempt mission and programmatic goals.

SECTION II: EVALUATION SCALE

Performance metrics documented within this instrument shall be measured using the following 5-point rating scale:

• 5 - Exceptional: Consistently exceeds core requirements; models organizational excellence and innovation.
• 4 - Exceeds Expectations: Frequently surpasses performance targets; demonstrates high reliability and initiative.
• 3 - Meets Expectations: Fully satisfies all job requirements; performs duties in a competent and consistent manner.
• 2 - Needs Improvement: Fails to consistently meet performance standards; requires targeted corrective action.
• 1 - Unsatisfactory: Fails to meet core job requirements; presents immediate operational or programmatic risk.

SECTION III: CORE COMPETENCY ASSESSMENT

(Evaluator to assign rating [1-5] and provide concrete operational justification.)

1. Mission Alignment & Stewardship:

   • Rating: [1-5]
   • Comments: [Insert detailed evaluation regarding commitment to organizational mission, ethical stewardship of charitable assets, and community engagement.]

2. Job-Specific Execution & Productivity:

   • Rating: [1-5]
   • Comments: [Insert detailed evaluation regarding quality, accuracy, timeliness, and volume of work output.]

3. Collaboration & Stakeholder Communication:

   • Rating: [1-5]
   • Comments: [Insert detailed evaluation of teamwork, cross-functional cooperation, and professional communication with donors, volunteers, board members, and beneficiaries.]

4. Compliance, Governance & Risk Management:

   • Rating: [1-5]
   • Comments: [Insert detailed evaluation regarding adherence to internal controls, grant compliance, privacy standards, and regulatory mandates.]

SECTION IV: GOAL SETTING FOR THE SUBSEQUENT REVIEW PERIOD

The Employee and Evaluator mutually establish the following Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) and operational objectives for the upcoming review cycle:

1. [Specific Objective 1, e.g., Successfully manage Q3 grant-funded program rollout within allocated budget.]
2. [Specific Objective 2, e.g., Complete specialized board governance training by Date.]
3. [Specific Objective 3, e.g., Improve donor retention metrics by X% through targeted outreach.]

SECTION V: PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT & SUPPORT

1. Organizational Commitment: The Organization agrees to provide the following resources, training, or support mechanisms to assist the Employee in achieving their objectives: [Insert Training, Mentorship, or Resource Commitments].
2. Employee Acknowledgment: The Employee acknowledges receipt of this evaluation, understands the performance expectations outlined herein, and accepts responsibility for executing the stated developmental goals.

---

4. SIGNATURES & ACKNOWLEDGMENT BLOCK

By signing below, the parties acknowledge that this performance review has been jointly reviewed, discussed, and finalized. Note: The Employee's signature indicates receipt of the document and does not necessarily indicate agreement with the contents.

EMPLOYER / EVALUATOR:

Signature: ____________________________________ Date: [Date]

Printed Name: [Evaluator Full Legal Name]

Title: [Evaluator Job Title]

---

EMPLOYEE:

Signature: ____________________________________ Date: [Date]

Printed Name: [Employee Full Legal Name]

Title: [Employee Job Title]

---

HUMAN RESOURCES / EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR (If applicable):

Signature: ____________________________________ Date: [Date]

Printed Name: [HR/ED Full Legal Name]

Title: [HR Director / Executive Director]

---

5. STEP-BY-STEP EXECUTION GUIDE

1. Preparation & Completion: The Evaluator must complete all rating sections and qualitative comments prior to the formal review meeting, ensuring objective, performance-based metrics are utilized.
2. In-Person / Virtual Review Conference: Conduct a structured one-on-one meeting between the Evaluator and Employee to discuss the ratings, address discrepancies constructively, and finalize the professional development goals outlined in Section IV.
3. Execution & Formal Filing: Obtain all required signatures and dates. Transmit the fully executed document to the Human Resources department within 3 business days of the review meeting for secure inclusion in the Employee's confidential personnel file.
4. Follow-Up & Monitoring: Schedule an interim check-in (e.g., at 90 days post-review) to monitor progress against the KPIs established in Section IV, ensuring compliance with non-profit operational governance standards.